Can You Figure Out What’s Missing?

I had a beautiful phone conversation with my father on Valentine’s Day.  Whenever we talk, he admits his difficulties dealing with his only daughter’s death, and I always feel uncomfortable telling him I don’t think I am suffering as much as he is, although we both know I was probably closest to Alex in the family.  We were the two youngest in the family, often relegated to suffer each other while the parents were away at some function and my older brother was gone because he was over 16 and could drive, and we were left in the house, often choosing to spend time alone, but just as often choosing to watch television together, to watch movies, to play board or card games, to discuss ideas, to read and talk about our reading with each other.  Our souls recognized each other as kindred spirits.  We did not always antagonize each other as some siblings relentlessly do.

My father told me a story, which I’d like to relate to you, and ask you one question: Can you figure out what’s missing?

My parents had just arrived at the house for an evening, out with four other couples for dinner bringing the final count to ten, even and base.  They arrived and immediately immersed themselves in conversation, splitting from each other, to grab a drink and converse with the different gendered groups.  Glasses of wine, of Mojitos, beers, and water held by all in the amber light, the house paneled in dark wood.  My father immediately began to involved himself in a conversation about the latest sermon, about the things he was learning in his Biblical Greek classes he takes at night at the Center for Biblical Studies, and about any new revelations.  My father has long been highly regarded in the church despite his distance from leadership–year after year refusing to become a deacon because he does not fully support the doctrine of the church, though he goes to church every week, and has gone every Sunday for over twenty years.

My mother gravitates toward the women and the kitchen.  She grabs a glass of wine, white wine because it is usually sweeter.  She talks about her job.  She works in the library.  She loves public service, and often spends much extra time unspooling and fixing audio tapes returned when a patron’s machine unexpectedly destroys the slender shiny tape.  She talks about the new names she has discovered on the computer sign-up, discussing how upsetting it is to ask a belligerent library patron to sign off because the computer is needed for another, the next on the sign up sheet.  She always, fastidiously, refers to every person in the library as a patron, even the homeless who spend their days in the building, especially in the winter.

The other men in my father’s conversation take his cue, and discuss aspects of classes they may be taking or teaching.  They talk about their work and the trials they are facing there.  One man, Mike, discusses his business, asking my father about his experiences as a small business owner.  They talk about the impending tax season.  My father listens and reflects on how things, even in a few years, have changed so much since he was running his own business, happy to be rid of it and retired.  He gives advice where he can, himself serving on our church’s Finance Committee and a regular co-teacher of Crown Ministries’ finance course based in biblical doctrine, co-taught with my mother.  Mike listens diligently, asking for details or explanations, feels relief when my father gives him the advice he has decided is the wisest of all the advice he has heard thus far.  The conversations moves on to Bob, who begins to talk about moving.

Most of the women do not work like my mother does, getting her job at the library when I was in sixth grade, realizing it was never to early to prevent empty nesting syndrome, my sister about to graduate from eighth grade and my brother already over halfway through high school, looking into colleges.  The women fill in conversation about their volunteer work with the church, with schools, with charitable enterprises in the city.  They talk to my mother about how much they admire that she has a job, that she’s maintained it.  They joke that she is now the breadwinner of the family since my father’s retirement.  They all laugh after this statement.  My mother laughs.  She has often made this joke as well.

The dinner is ready to serve.  Everyone takes a seat, couples ultimately deciding to sit across from each other, as tradition would dictate.  The women and men are mixed.  More drinks are poured, more wine is drunk, more conversation about work and commitments and church is had with many bad jokes, equal parts laughter and groaning depending on the quality (laughter for societal observations, groaning for puns).  They talk about traveling, missions trips, upcoming fundraisers and the church yard sale and the massive numbers of volunteers needed.  The end date of construction near a major intersection is hotly debated.  Discussion of the ever-changing speed limits is brought up and just as quickly moved past.  Observations about possibly moving from one couple elicit questions of where and what kind of property they are looking for.  Will they live near the husband’s or wife’s family?

Soon enough salads, chicken, ham, green beans, mashed potatoes, and brownies and ice cream are eaten, and the couples disperse for the night, my parents walking to their own car, my father driving, my mother sitting in the passenger seat with the back support (necessary after an old injury).

“Did you notice–?” my father began to ask, leaving the question unfinished as he looked over at my mother, hoping he wasn’t being paranoid.

“Notice that no one spoke about their children?” she answered. “Yes. Everyone seemed to be trying very hard to avoid it.”

“Because of Alex?” he asked.

“Because of Alex,” she confirmed.

 

How Many Times Are you Supposed to Cry When You’re Mourning?

With the celebration of every holiday comes the reminder that there is one less person of the many less people here now to celebrate it.  These events are small.  Martin Luther King, Jr. Day, President’s Day, Valentine’s Day.  These are not major holidays like Christmas or Thanksgiving, but they are not the small and persistent reminders that there are things like equality, history, and love that make up our lives.  With my sister dead, there seems to be just a little less love.  I miss that love greatly.

I have been reading listening to the book The Namesake by Jhumpa Lahiri by way of the wondrous app Overdrive–which lets you download e-books and audiobooks from your local public library with your library card.  It is a lovely book.  I remember racing through one Lahiri’s other books, The Interpreter of Maladies, five or so years ago, on a bus to and from Baltimore. The first story had been heartbreaking.  The others moving in their own way.  That was back when I was trying to read all of the Pulitzer Prize winning novels.  I have not achieved that goal, although every year, I seem to get a little closer, then farther with the announcement of a new winner.  How glad I was in 2012 when the committee decided not to announce a winner, and that I would have to add no new book to the usually lengthening list.  I spent time reading the slim volume Tinkers, and probably just as much time wondering why that book had won the Pulitzer for the same reasons The Killer Angels or The Road or Gilead or To Kill a Mockingbird. Back to the point…

The Namesake begins with a man in India named Ashoke, growing up, and experiencing a tragic accident on a train.  What follows is a charming and lovely novel of Ashoke’s life as he moves to America, gets married, has children, names his son after his favorite author, Gogol, who was an important figure in his memory on the train where he suffered an accident, nearly died. As I read through the book there was a moment when an unexpected death occurred.  All at once, I mourned with the characters in the novel.  At once I knew what it meant to see a dead relative laying lifeless.  I knew what it was to get that unexpected phone call from an unexpected person at an unexpected hour.  I knew what it was to suddenly have lost someone and only be able to hold on to the most recent memory to justify that they might not yet truly be dead.  I know what it means to go back to a childhood home to honor death and pay it respect.

It is a kindred moment, when two people suddenly realize they are both in mourning.  It is a free pass to cry, to become overly sentimental, to discuss how uncomfortable everyone else is around you, to worry that it is actually you who are making everyone else uncomfortable.

I do not know why I find myself searching for award winning books.  I do not know why I suddenly feel the need to read all of the Pulitzer Prize winning novels.  I do not think if I read them all I will suddenly be able to write one, that I will suddenly be America embodied, but I do know that there is an achievement in me that I have not yet accomplished; Alex’s death only more closely reminding me that there is not unlimited time to find out what things I want to achieve with my life.  What things I want to do, what books I want to read, who I would want to be known as after I might leave my body, or after my body might fail.  I’m still not certain about my soul, or if I have one.

The Namesake reminded me that there are other people, fake and made up, real and close to me, who lived through the same things I have.

School was cancelled yesterday, so I did not go into work.  I was sad about this since Thursday would be the day I talk to Mike about his dead brother.  It would be our first chance to talk since last week. Now that school is cancelled there might be another week until our chance to speak again.  By that time, too many days may have elapsed for the conversation to be meaningful.  It would not be right to ask him ho he is doing in the middle of class, surrounded by friends and peers, taking time away from the tight ship I normally keep to wander in memory.  I would not want to put him through that.

But on this day, I can hardy feel as though he is all right.  I am still not entirely fine.  Just this morning I had to stop listening to an audiobook because I was getting to sad because a person close to a character died.  That, I think, is not a normal response.  Maybe it is.  Afterwards, I cried at a video of prisoner fathers dancing with their daughters. <See link: http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2013/06/virginia-jail-holds-father-daughter-dance-for-prisoners/> No shame.  But concern.  If this is where I am, where is he?  If this is where I am, am I emotionally stunted? Should I be crying more? Less?  Should I have already gotten this out of the way? Did I not connect enough when she died?  Where those days spent in bed, crying, avoiding, remembering, embracing, just as ineffective as these words?  Or are they both working?

I am grateful there are things like mourning that aren’t scientific, that cannot be broken down in to action reaction, balanced equations, formulas and predictable outcomes.  I am grateful that there is gray space.  I am grateful I don’t know how many times I am supposed to cry during the mourning period, or how long the mourning period is supposed to last.  I do not want to know how far behind the curve I might be.

I Live Life on the Internet Better Than Reality

Your daily habits online are predictable.  The websites may fall in and out of favor over time, but your review of them does not.  There are your standbys.  There is Facebook (and all the links your friends post) and Tumblr, Twitter and StumbleUpon, Instagram, Reddit,  Buzzfeed, Sporcle, Email, and any research you need to do about that pie recipe or the latest Olympic performance update from last night that you may have missed while you were asleep.  When you wake up it is the same pattern.  Facebook first.  Avoid email until you’re at work, or later when you will be more lucid.  Click the links, like the article about the depressing state of twentysomething economics, skip the article about feminism and the latest viral video, click the link of the adorable cat video but don’t like so people don’t judge you, write happy birthday on the friend du jour’s wall.  Facebook makes it so easy to casually care.

You move to StumbleUpon because you can’t quite handle the serious e-mails in  your inbox, and you thumbs up what you’ve come to expect as the extraordinary pictures of the night sky, but get bored with all of the comics you don’t understand about computer nerdery that is labeled under Humor, but should be better categorized as Anthropology.  Make plans to study this cultural subset later.  Move to Tumblr and reblog things that will make you seem smart and funny.  Build up the courage to give terse replies to those emails.  Go to sporcle and play a few quizzes where you know you’ll score in the 99th percentile of all quiz takers along with 20% of all other quiz takers.  Don’t feel bad about it.  Close your computer.  Pack your bags.  Leave for work.  Repeat process upon arrival.

I had a routine.  It was nice.  I’d wake up in the morning, take a ten minute shower, dry off, get dressed, make coffee, drink coffee and eat cereal while watching part of a TV show streamed from Netflix or HBOGO or Amazon Prime–comedies mostly, easy to fit twenty-two minutes with a breakfast.  Dramas.  Sometimes animated favorites: The Lion King, Robin Hood…I even tried Brother Bear (not good).  Put on dress clothes, brush teeth.  Add extra heavy winter clothes to prepare for my bicycle commute, pray my nads don’t ascend from the cold, pack my lunch.  Run back to my room because I likely forgot several things including, but not limited to: pens, pencils, stylus for my iPad (with laser pointer to annoy students), phone, headphones, wallet, change or dollar bills for the vending machine (just in case), computer, graded papers, ungraded papers, novels, comics, graphic novels, textbooks, teacher instruction books, snacks, candy, or an extra pain of socks if it’s wet outside from snow or rain.

One of my former routines was the happy birthday moment.  I would, as so many do, check the Birthday Notification section of Facebook to see whose birthday it was for that day, decide who I cared to wish a happy birthday, and left the others alone.  I have not yet become one of those people who defriends others, either regularly in small doses, or rarely in large batches, or anywhere in between.  I do know that my friends list has remained relatively stable as I’ve reached a point in life where I rarely add new friends–not the way my fake-online-social life exploded when I was in college, or just after–when there were seemingly hundreds of us, all the same with internships and externships and years spent abroad and little actual work experience as we began entry level jobs with bright aspirations and big hopes of larger success come faster than previous generations expected or allowed.

My news feed is filled with these half-friends made after college, and so friends not as close as the others that I have slowly drifted away from as we moved to different cities to make our way and find our own success.  A wall street trader and big time business head level buyer in New York City.  A lawyer in Texas.  An entrepreneur in New Orleans.  An engineer in Los Angeles.  A writer in Miami.  A legal aspirant as a current aide in Washington DC.  These are the people whose birthday rise up along with those I worked with for a few months before they decided they wanted to apply for the creative writing masters from that surprisingly good midwestern school not known for much else.  They have been lost the last four months.  I have said happy birthday to none of these people.  I hope they haven’t noticed.

The process of saying happy birthday to one another has always struck me as an odd, habit; the idea of a celebration of a birthday oddly difficult to define, and I’ve always liked the idea of the birthdate being something that is an inaccuracy–calling back to the question that abortionists and anti-abortionists have been arguing and debating forever: When does life begin?  Whenever the answer is (I really could care less), the idea of saying happy birthday is an affirmation of that life–a process by which, if enough people post on my Facebook wall might convince me that I am alive.  I have long thought my birthday is a miserable day.  I have a summer birthday.  As a child and student, there was always a question of whether or not anyone would be available for my birthday party–there is a type of Pavlovian conditioning that has taught me not to bother celebrating my own birthday.

Yesterday I began to write iterations of “Happy Birthday!” on my friends’ walls, a reaffirmation of our friendship, a reaffirmation of their live and their aliveness, a reaffirmation of my own life in my ability to recognize life.  I will celebrate the birthdays of others, if only because there is one less birthday to celebrate in my life and I remember everyday that, because there is life, it should be celebrated.

The Cruelest Murder I Could Ever Imagine

I’ve mentioned before that I am a teacher.  I teach high school.  I have taught English and history. This has been my job since college.  For years.  This has become a job, to a profession and a passion.  It’s my life.  I love Saturday School, which I rode home from today in a sort of state of misery after suffering through the morning with a small headache.  But it was still good while I was there. I was still working with students, I was still getting work done.  Students were learning, mainly just working and working on better grades. It was great.  But that’s beside the point.  My main point of this “I’m a teacher” paragraph is to emphasize two things: I am a teacher, I am surrounded by students.  And I really enjoy the job.

I am not the most emotionally available person, teacher, friend, brother, son, etc.  I try to be dispassionate about much that happens in my classroom as a source of objectivity and sanity in what is normally a storm of hormones and teenage logic (or illogic, as it often is).  So I was surprised when one of my students came up to me after class and asked about my dead sister.  “What did it feel like?”

“I felt like shit,” I said.  I don’t normally curse in front of my students.  I make a point not to as most teachers do.  But I felt like it was an honest word to use.  “I don’t normally cry and I cried for hours and hours and days and days.”  I’m not the most eloquent person.  I’m (usually) better when writing.  He started crying at the words, like he had suddenly been given permission.

“Because you’re the only other person I know who’s going through the same thing right now.”  Oh right. His brother had been shot a month before.  I forgot about that.

I remembered when Alex died, I wanted to tell everyone how amazing she was.  How inspiring.  How delightful.  How much I would miss her.  I wanted to yell at people that the world had lost a treasure, a good person, quantifiably in the third standard deviation of good.  Maybe the second.  But one of the best in the world.  I’m guessing I’m middling to lower than average, but Alex?  She was one of the best.  “Tell me about him,” I asked, hoping Mike (we’ll call him Mike for the sake of anonymity…and because I know he’d laugh if he ever found this at the idea of being named Mike) would want to talk about his brother they way I wanted to talk about my sister, the way I had talked to my classes about how wonderful my trip to Bali had been, how amazing she had been, how close we were, how rare I felt to have such a good relationship with my sister.  It was a pride I wanted to shine.

He started talking.  Mike (16) told me how his older brother (19) was his model and inspiration.  How he was always the marker for how to act like a man.  His brother, like a lot of kids in the big cities of the great north east, played ball…but really played ball.  He was a basketball player in college, with a bright future ahead of him.  He lived the life of a dedicated student and passionate athlete who was following his dream.  Who would want to kill someone like that?  Mike told me two guys came by and shot him because he was successful.  Because he was getting out.  Because he was good.  Mike said he was killed because he was better, shot because they were jealous of him.

This was not the first murder a student had talked to me about, but it is the cruelest murder I could ever imagine.  I had no response for a murder so pointless and petty.  Mike had been crying through all of it.  I kept asking him questions.  What was your brother like?  What was  your favorite memory of him?  What did you all like to do together?  I couldn’t come up with enough questions until he finally asked, “How do you keep it together?”

“Keep it together? Mike, I didn’t keep it together at all.  I came back to work and sunk into it so that I could put my brain on autopilot against every other thought that was about Alex.  Does everything you see remind you of him?” Of course it did.  I told him how a coupon for razor blades welled my eyes with waves worth of tears, how grass in the sidewalk or radio commercials took me back.  I asked him about those things too.  “Can you talk to your mom about it?” I asked.  She’s the one person with whom I have the most difficult time talking about Alex’s death.  I think I found a kindred spirit when he said he didn’t talk to her about it.  That she barely tried to bring it up but when she did he avoided the conversation.

Thirty minutes later he left saying he felt much better about it.  I told him to write about it.  He said that only made it feel worse.  I told him he might need to feel worse.  I told him grief is kind of like an accident on the highway.  Everything slows down, and then comes to a stop before freeing up after that tightest place where the accident is.  I told him grief might just be like that.  That you might only get over grief after you have traveled its pathways for a long time and after you’ve gotten to the root of your greatest pain and pulled it out so you could cradle it and take it with you.  I don’t know if I told him the right thing.  I only know how I have felt these last few months.  I only know I can pretend I’m not sad, but I remember the day I worked after finding out about my sister’s death, and all I wanted was anything else.  It wasn’t until I thought long and deeply about her that I found a love beyond the pain.

Why People Change

“I know people change. I just wanted to know why.”

Last summer I tutored the child of a woman who was running and educational leadership program in the city.  As the teacher she chose to work with her son, I felt honored and nervous.  She herself had been a teacher before becoming a principal before becoming the leader of the educational leadership program.  When I first met with her, before I would even meet her son, she mentioned my involvement in the program.  “Maybe we’ll see you here next year,” she said with a twinkle in her eye. “Oh, I doubt it.  I’m not sure I’d want to be a principal,” I said with a laugh, leaving with her son to have lunch and see if we would get along, considering her was in high school and much older and more discerning of adults than younger students are.  It’s much easier to tutor the young than it is the old.

A month later I was in Bali with my sister and the idea of being a teacher with summers off was the ideal.  We talked about the future traveling we could accomplish during the winter and summer vacations.  We made plans, discussing her future countries of interest where she wanted to live, and discussing my preferences for vacation, hoping there would be some overlap there.  She complained of the difficulty of working in the EU without citizenship, and I spoke of India and Africa.  She ultimately settled on possibly staying in Bali another year.  Or moving back to Australia where she had lived for a few years before that.  Or coming back to the United States for a while to plan her next move.  Maybe she would live in South or Central America.  There were so many options in August.

Two months later my sister was dead from wounds sustained in an accident in Bali.  I could not express how I felt.  I could not determine how I felt or how I was supposed to feel.  Scores of movies and books about loss and mourning with characters going through the experience and I hadn’t learned a thing about what to expect or what to do.  I could only feel a little hollower for having lived after my sister’s death.  I traveled to Florida, back home, to wait with the dearly beloved for the arrival of our dearly related.  Sitting on the airplane coming home I tried to read or write.  I bought a beer instead.  The first time I’d bought alcohol on a plane.  I bought another one on the connecting flight from Charlotte to Tallahassee and slept for forty minutes.  There was no hope and the beer helped me forget.  There were no options by October.

There was one option in October.  A week or two before the death of my sister, I sat down with my boss to discuss my future.  I was wondering about possible upheaval in the coming years and wanted to discuss my role and where I’d fit best.  It was a meeting where I was going to ask that my role be minimized as I might want to leave.  The conversations with my sister over the summer inspired me to think about going out and exploring the world.  But he offered me the possibility of a job (dependent on budget), and left me with that.  In the wake of my sister’s death, I began to grasp at the hope I’d held outsider of her, and this was the first and most obvious option.  I told my boss if the money was there, I would accept.  End of story.

The change in job would require a new certification–a school leadership degree or certification.  There are many options for school leadership opportunities, but the cheapest option, the free option was run through the district, by a woman whose son I had tutored that past summer.  So I applied.  I went to the pre-application dinner. I submitted my application.  I wrote out my qualifications and degrees and experiences, and even videotaped myself answering questions. I did everything they asked and hoped I was good enough.  I was passed through to the phone interview, that seemed to go well.  I try and talk my way through phone interviews, hoping I’ve answered the questions they ask, but continuing on down the rabbit hole I’ve burrowed my mind into.  I was passed on to the final group interview with other candidates having passed through the process.  We met together on a Saturday morning to do activities and prove ourselves one last time for the final bar.

The morning was difficult and I was nervous through the entire thing.  My words from the past summer echoing in my ears and burning red on my cheeks and pumping fast through my heart.  I felt as though everyone knew I was a turncoat.  I was the liar, the Benedict Arnold in the room, and they were the honest revolutionaries.  I was monitored by the woman whose sun I tutored.  And then, at the very end of the day, she asked, “Do you remember?” Yes. “When you said those things?” Yes. “Said you didn’t want to do school leadership?” Yes. “What changed?” I sat there and waited for anything but the God’s honest to come to my mind.  When I want to be, I am a convincing liar, but I could think of nothing.

“…”  I waited. “…”  No answer better than the truth presented itself.  No spin. “… Uhm… Well… Honestly… My sister died.  She was only two years older than me.  I just thought I should take hold of opportunities I have while I’m here…you know? Does that answer your question?”  The last question a reflex of my habit of diving for an answer that is often close but not exactly what was asked.  “Yes,” she said. “I know people change. I just wanted to know why.”  And then we went our separate ways.  I wondered if motivation from a death is a good thing or a bad thing.  I have not decided.  I wonder if I ever will.

 

Why I Cannot Let My Sister Die

In two weeks, it will be four months since I learned of the death of my sister (Alex) and I cannot let her die.  She was an inspiration, effortlessly joyful and funny and just as effortlessly mean and annoyed.  She was real, human, humane. Over the course of her twenty-nine year, and our twenty-seven together, I came to love her the most of all my family members–close in the way only siblings can be close.   She inspired me to go beyond the boundaries the small people in our small town build for themselves, and did it again when I had pushed beyond Tallahassee, and needed to move beyond Florida, and then beyond the United States.  She was a world traveler, a teacher, a mentor, a friend, a sister, a daughter, an explorer.  What would the world be without teachers or explorers? I cannot let my sister die.

When we were children, my sister, my brother, and I would play, but with my brother being three years older than my sister and five years old than me, it was most often my sister who was left to entertain me.  She would pretend the floor was lava and throw pillow cushions in order to get across to the kitchen. (Tile is lava proof.) e would do this as we watched “The Lion King” for the 107th time, singing the songs, and fast forwarding through all the parts we didn’t like. (The speech at night with the dad.  The stampede.)  She would record cassette tapes of our radio show, and we would make up the advertisements, the show topics, and choose the music.  After a family trip, she would dutifully organize the photographs and mementos and colored paper and pencils and create scrapbooks.  What would the world do without the effortlessly creative?  I cannot let my sister die.

As we grew up, she began to find her favorite movies.  The remake of “Sabrina” starring Julia Ormond and Greg Kinnear and Harrison Ford was one of her favorites.  She also loves Moulin Rouge and anything with Johnny Depp, but “Sabrina” was in her Top Three Favorite Films of All Time, if not her Number One Favorite Film Ever.  It was a sappy love story that our parents rented one night for the three of us to watch while they were out.  The TV our babysitter.  Really the oldest brother was, but Alex fell in love with that movie that night, and she would watch it over and over, judging all possible friendships by their affinity for this particular movie. She was a woman of principal.  Do principles die as easily as the humans who champion them?

When she was with her friends, they realized that Tallahassee was not the most exciting of places.  So she would take her camera and begin to pose her friends in various positions in her house and let a murder mystery take place.  Some mysterious hands would look as though it was shoving one girl down the stairs.  The next photo would reveal her at the bottom of the stairs surrounded by all the suspects.  The photo book culminated in one of the friends being pushed off a parking garage and then pictured lying dead at the bottom.   Then another photo with the identity of the murderer revealed as she looked over the railing at her handiwork below.  Of course it had been the redhead.  She looked guilty in all the photographs.  My sister was the inventor of games, the creator of stories, a comedienne and photographer.   How could anyone let someone like that die?

When she would return from college, she would watch “Friends” and obsess over that show.  She had, by her death seen every episode at least four times. Every episode.  There are over one hundred episodes.  There are over two hundred episodes.  There are 236 episodes.  And she watched them all.  At least four times over.  They were a series of birthday and Christmas presents over a few years from various family members, depending on who was having trouble finding her a present besides something “Friends” related. We would take Sporcle quizzes about the show and she would ace them.  She took a “Friends” tour of New York and was able to answer every question or predict each bit of trivia the tour guide asked about on the bus.  The tour guide said that had never happened before.  Alex was a person the likes of which had never happened before.  I cannot let that spirit die.

One summer I was studying in Paris and she was interning in London so we met up in London to have a good time.  She took me to have a full English breakfast (ate the whole thing…even the tomato…it was delicious) because she knew I loved to eat.  She took me to the Tate Modern because we both love art.  She posed on Millennium Bridge for a jumping photo.  She took jumping photos everywhere.  One of my last memories of her is trying to take a jumping picture of her. I had so much trouble with the timing.  We saw a musical (Les Miserables), rode the London Eye, and I suffered through dancing at a club and high tea.  She always knew how to plan the perfect trip for herself or any visitor.  I have never learned such things.  Maybe I was never given that talent.  I’m trying to learn her talent now.  I cannot let my sister die.

We met together once in the great Up North, in Philadelphia.  We ate cheese steaks, and visited the Rocky statue, running up the Art Museum steps just like in the movie.  We saw the art, but that was just a bonus.  She loved the Rodin sculptures.  I knew she would.  We ate delicious food (not cheese steaks) and spent some time watching an episode of “Friends.” Were that the last moments it would have been a good ending to our friendship.  But there are so many things that my sister was that no is anymore.  I must find a way to be all these things.  I cannot let my sister die.

Words with Dead Friends

A confession: one day last year, within the first two months of my sister’s (Alex’s) death, I was useless and gained about six pounds because of it.  I normally ride my bicycle to and from work every day (about four miles, about eight miles total distance), and often run in the summer months or row in the winter months.  I stopped all of that the week my sister died.  I tried to row, but was not very successful, often losing effort less than halfway through an exercise I easily finished the week before.  Then I returned home where I was expected to sit and be.  I was not expected (or supposed) to run or exercise, although it wasn’t forbidden.  It was just a comfort to be around.  There were many people who came in and out of the house and I became the newest member of the welcoming committee (please leave your casserole or cookies on the counter).

I tried running once, but there is different air in Florida than there is in the cities of the Up North.  Florida was immediately twenty degrees warmed in October.  The air still warm and sticky with humidity, rife with swamp air and still-moving in swamp motion. I tried running once while I was home, took the same old paths I ran in high school, laid out with my odometer before the revolution of the internet and Run Keeper or any of the other apps that can do what only my car odometer or a very close attention to maps and their keys and legends could accomplish.   The air stuck in my lungs after only a few tenths of a mile. After one mile, I was spent.  Less than two months prior to my run I had finished a half-marathon.

Tallahassee was getting to me.  Alex’s death was getting to me.  It was like I was an addict and I needed to sweat her out, only there was no amount of sweating that would take care of my problem.  I returned to my city in the great Up North and still tried sweating, but couldn’t sweat it out.  I turned to my rowing machine.  It was a thought out summer purchase.  As a secret, teachers spend mad amounts of money in the summer and almost no money at all beside the requisites during the school year.  I do, at least.  It was my brilliant plan for winter exercise so I wouldn’t have to brave the cold beyond my daily bicycle commute.  I really enjoyed the machine. It was repetitive and challenging the way running is–a game of man versus self, where there is always a clear winner and loser and it’s always me on both sides. Running or rowing, hobbies for the self-obsessed and self-possessed.

One night while I was rowing, I became overwhelmed with thoughts and feelings of and for my sister.  But I was in the middle of forty minutes of rowing.  I had set a workout.  I wasn’t going to stop.  I might not make my time limit, but I was going to finish.  So there and then in those moments, in ragged breaths between the pushing of my legs and the pulling of my arms, I began to speak a letter to my dead sister.  “Dear Alex,” I began. “I am very upset at your sudden…departure.” I told her everything, spoke into the walls of my basement.  Let the secrets and admissions and embarrassments and feelings float up to the ceiling and left them to find their own way out of the basement.

I told her of my great sadness, and the phone calls with friends were we discussed books that she would likely love.  I told her how Dad and Mom were taking it.  I told her about her ex-boyfriend and all he did to ensure the safe return of her body home to Tallahassee. I told her about my brother and his wife and how happy our niece had been, romping all over the church before and after her funeral service.  I told her about the food and all the people who showed up to celebrate her life.  I thanked her for living a good life.  I told her how upset I was with her, for leaving so suddenly, and how difficult it had been to manage emotions.  I told her I wished we had some time to discuss The Fault In Our Stars by John Green.  I’d noticed the book, creased and cracked in her possessions that were flown back, but she’d never mentioned that she’d read it.  I wondered what she thought of it.  I hoped she’d liked it better than other books she’d read or was reading.  I mourned all of the books we’d no longer be able to discuss, and I apologized to her for recommending Gone Girl because Alex found the book all too “messed up.”  I told her I was sorry for not continuing to play her in Words with Friends.  I guess I’d been a sore loser after the last game we had played together.

My sister loved to play Words with Friends.  I would pick up the game and play it obsessively for a few weeks at a time.  She was always more meticulous and stable than me when it came to such pursuits. She would continue to play with our mother, her ex-boyfriend.  She used the chat platform as a way to maintain another form of communication with those she felt closest to.  She would always berate me over GChat to finish the game she was usually winning.  I opened up the app Words with Friends on my iPad the other day. My last game was with Alex.  She had played the word CRONE to start the game horizontally, left justified so as to make a double word count for 18 points.  Even after death she still manages to beat me.  Thinking about it as her winning spirit living on makes me smile, makes me happier and a little less sad.

The Saddest Photograph in the World

I took a photograph secretly. It was a moment filled with guilt.  I told myself that it was a bad idea.  I held my phone in one hand, a tissue in the other. I was fiddling with one app or another.  I had just come from the other room where the body of my dead sister Alex rested.  I did not want to think about that thing, her body, that looked so empty and unused and unlike what my sister had looked like.  I saw here, just a few months before, walking around, running, riding  a bike, swimming, snorkeling, eating, screaming and dancing. The thing that laid before us was something else, had become something else. Instead of thinking about the transformative properties of life and death, about my sister’s body as a vessel, I left the room after a few moments, an untold amount of minutes and seconds and went to the sitting area in the front, a parlor for death.

My mother and father went in first, clearing the way for their two sons and a friend.  We were allowed to go into the room at our leisure, the family was, but mother and father said they would go in first, they needed to go in first.  I did not argue.  My brother did not argue.   It was not a time for an excess of words or the expression of conflicting opinions. There were other figures that floated around the funeral home, but I didn’t notice them as we waited in the foyer, listening for the sounds of crying and grief we had accommodated so well over the past two weeks.  It had taken seven days for my sister’s body to be returned to the United States from Indonesia.  Then another four days to get home to us.  Damn government holidays and three day weekends.

When my mother and father came out, I was already prepared based on the sounds from the other room.  I had heard these noises at night, from other rooms in the house, over the phone.  It was the sound of grief, of utter loss, of great and immendable sadness. There was nothing we could say as the sounds filtered out, so I sat and noticed how solid everything in the funeral home was.  The couches were heavy and solid, without much comfort.  I remember thinking that was ironic.  The carpet was large and heavy and thick.  The arms of the chairs were solid polished wood.  Everything was finely upholstered.  There were tissue boxes everywhere.  The small boxy ones that always empty so quickly, wearing a pathetic disguise of covers with flowers painted on porcelain/plastic, or metal engraved with meaningless details or patterns.  I do not remember any pictures on the walls.

We were told we could go in and see her.  My mother saying, “I just had to be sure. I just had to be sure. I just had to be sure it was her.  A mother needs to know.  What if it wasn’t?” I understood. I was filled with equal parts dread and curiosity.  I had thought more than once, What if it isn’t her? before imagining my family in the midst of some international scandal, my sister under protective secret service, running from the law after witness a terrible crime.  The whole story immediately popped into my head.  The beginning: a portrait of a family in grief, moving quickly into the conflict, a wrong body, followed by the breathless pursuit around the world for my sister and the truth. Instead, I went into the room, finding what my mother had found.  The body that lay there did and did not look like my sister, but was unequivocally her body.

I had already read the police report from the Balinese Police.  I read about the traffic that morning, the work the government was doing that was causing some difficulty around a large roundabout.  The large truck in front of my sister as it slowed to a stop.  My sister slowing to a stop with another biker on the other side behind the truck.  About the truck behind her that didn’t slow so quickly, striking both cyclists, leaving one sore, and the other dead, bleeding out through the neck after striking a piece of metal hanging out the back of the truck in front of her.  I knew something would be wrong with her face and neck.  I was prepared for it.  So when I entered the room and saw the coffin on the right, I turned and moved quickly because I wanted to see her and make sure she was okay.

Her face was different.  The mortician had done an admirable job.  Her jaw looked somewhat reconstructed.  Her neck looked patched, different colors in certain areas.  Her nose looked off kilter.  She would have never held that expression in life.  In death? I moved my eyes up to hers, they were a bit sunken in.  Her forehead, though.  Her forehead was undeniable hers.  Her forehead and her wrist.  Her stomach and fallen in, and her hip bones protruded awkwardly, but her forehead and her wrist were hers.  I wanted to hold her hand one last time.  I wanted to touch her hair.  I wanted to do completely morbid things, and was ashamed so I left and sat down in the waiting room, pulling a tissue and dabbing my eyes while others took so much time.

My brother came out next and sat twenty feet away.  The room was far too large.  He dropped his head and held it in his hands, crying unabashedly.  My mother came out next, and seeing me doing all right, went to my brother, sitting on the firm arm of the solid chair and held him.  With my phone in one hand, and the scene in front of me so perfect and sad, I took my phone and brought up the camera, angled so slightly, and took a picture.  I felt so guilty, I deleted the photograph a week later.  I chalked the decision up to insanity by grief. I don’t have it anymore.  There were no photos taken that week.  There is not proof of our grief any more, and I find myself wanting the photograph back. It would remind me that I am so much happier now.

No More Devil Words

Pronouns (e.g. he, she, it, them, they, their, himself, yourself, you, etc.) have become devils words to me.  They have become the words of intimate fear, uttered in my childhood home as though ghosts themselves, always in reference to Alex.  But Alex is no longer Alex.  Alex is she, as in, “She would have wanted it that way.” As in, “I don’t know where she is.”  Alex is also her, as in, “Why did God take her from us?”  As in, “Do you want any of her pictures or books?” As in, “I don’t know what I’m going to do with her art projects, but I can’t bear to let them go.”  (NOTE: All sentences we’ve said, myself included, in the wake of my sister’s death.)  I wonder if using pronouns makes her more distant and remote and discussable when it isn’t Alex, real and present.  But she or her, distant and possibly unreal, or at the very least, without corporeal form.

These pronouns have begun to drive me into madness at the sound of them.  My father says something that breaks my heart.  Something small but difficult. We were discussing the break, and he mentions that New Year’s Day has been the hardest day in a while.  “I can’t imagine a whole year without her.”  He said something like that.  I might have the words wrong, but the sentiment is there and full and real and honest and difficult.  I had no follow up. I want to shake my parents awake, to point out to my father that if he says her name it will make it easier.  I want to tell him that saying her will only fill the space with imaginings of her and who she was. I want to tell him it will be all right, but I also want to tell him that Alex was and Alex is are only different in tense, not love or memory.

I have been conscious of many things since my sister’s death.  I have been aware of my failings to let my feelings become publicly admittable things, like announcements for upcoming Open Mic Nights or my thoughts on the latest episodes of whatever TV show I’ve been watching to distract myself in the morning while I eat a bowl of cereal and drink a cup of coffee and avoid my feelings that I’ve kept corked and inside, chewing at the underside of my skin and bones and organs like worms, like cancer.  And I have been aware of that choice and I live and slowly die with all of those feelings left unspoken, but fully written, with you all to hear and pay attention to or ignore as you see fit.  I have been thoughtful about never saying my sister was lost.  Because she wasn’t lost.  She has always been found.  This time, found dead, and with that pronouncement found for the last time.

I have also been aware of the pronoun.  It has helped to be teaching about common SAT writing test errors that include pronoun usage.  It has been nice to talk to students about case and number agreement and how the SAT will often try to confuse the inexperienced reader with small shifts that go unnoticed except to the practiced eye.  It has been a kind outlet for pronoun usage that I would not let myself succumb to as a blogger, a journaler, or a conversationalist.  Whenever referring to my sister, it has always been, my sister, my dead sister, my dead sister Alex, my sister Alex, or Alex.  It has rarely been she, and never in conversation, with intimates, best friends, coworkers, or students.  It has always been in reference to the concrete and specific person she was to me.  She was and will always be the woman who was a girl and even through the transition between the two: my sister.

At this point, three and a half months since her death, the questions about how I am doing, about her, have almost entirely ceased.  Thank goodness.  I have been tired of saying, in various iterations, how sad I am.  On a phone call with an old college friend, within the week of learning about my sister’s death, she asked how I was, and I said: “I feel indelibly sad. Indelibly.  Is that a word?  What does that word mean?”  She laughed, because she finds my eternal confusion about the English language despite my status as an English teacher to be hilarious, and irony of ironies. She responds saying some definition to the effect of permanence, and the definition fits.  The usage was correct.  And I respond saying, “Yes, indelibly sad.  That is exactly how I feel.”  She said that was one of the saddest things she had ever heard. Then she changed the topic to books. We can both easily talk about books.

I used to read books about a death and the marks that death left on those still around and alive and willing to feel.  I always felt distant from that, and felt it a bit unreal but beautiful because the descriptions were always so heartfelt and heartbreaking.  Now I feel too close to those moments.  I have recently been reading and just finished a book, John Henry Days by Colson Whitehead.  It is an extraordinary book, and I recommend it.  But there is a scene where a body is buried by hand and I because so distraught at the idea I had to put the book down for a while before I could return to the narrative as a narrative, after I had stopped imagining myself the one digging with dirt stuck up under my fingernails, thick and moist and chalking as it dried.  I have known that feeling, and I would feel it again in an attempt to do one last thing for my sister, because I would have done anything for Alex if given the chance.  My last great act was to fly halfway across the world to see my sister. I would bury Alex if I had to.

 

Everything’s Not Lost

When my sister died, her ex-boyfriend but friend, helped the family take care of her possession in Bali, as he lived in Australia and was better able to handle the situation. When he arrived in Florida, he mentioned as the family sat around in the living room, the large TV that normally dominated the room as the center of activity off as our pastor was visiting, that Alex, my sister, our cause, wanted the song “Yellow” by Coldplay to be played at her funeral.  My mother had been thinking about Christian songs to play, and I could tell the idea made her a bit uncomfortable.  But, as she said, if Alex wanted it, we’ll make it happen.  So we made it happen.  “Yellow.”  Apparently Chris Martin, lead singer of Coldplay, has said that the title word refers to brightness, hope, devotion–the mood of the band.  What a perfect song to memorialize Alex. She was always bright and full of hope.

“Really?” I remember her asking while we were having a pseudo-serious conversation at our family’s beach house in Florida (why live in Florida if you don’t own a beach house?).  “Really?”  We had been talking about her experiences living in Bali, and she had not been having the best experience.  She wasn’t the biggest fan of her workplace, although she loved her students.  She wasn’t the biggest fan of the locals or the country, and she was having difficulty making friends.  We were talking about how she wanted some of the family to come visit her, as we never had before in all of her years living abroad (six-ish), so I said I would.  “Really?” was all she could say.  She didn’t believe me, and I didn’t believe myself.  That one off Skype conversation during my spring break vacation turned into the trip that dominated my summer vacation–the last time I would see my sister before her early exit.

The decision to go to Bali

The decision to go to Bali

Verbal diarrhea sounds gross because it is.  It is the excessive use of words when fewer words will say the same thing.  Most people I know suffer from it.  Most writers I know bury themselves in it.  After looking back over this blog, this writing exercise, this catalog of acceptance and death and mourning and grief and happiness that you have joined with me in exploring has suffered from verbal diarrhea too.  There were nights when I felt magical, the words flowing from my brain to the keyboard to the box where letters and words and paragraphs would mysteriously take shape, and in shockingly little time, there an update would be, perfectly encapsulated in about 1,000 words of an update on my feelings concerning my sister’s recent death, now becoming a thing of the past and history and memory rather than a present and current experience.

I want to apologize to everyone who reads this, for those past updates when I would write every word flowing through my mind following up the last even when it wasn’t best, with my heart and all that is in it.  I recently published my 30th post yesterday, a milestone of about 30,000 words, give or take a few hundred, which marks this as my longest writing project, aside from my many failed notebooks that grows slowly year by year.  Another small spiral bound notebook picked up at a CVS or Rite Aid or Walgreen’s, all in different colors: lime green, pink, yellow, green, light blue, red. I’m currently working in a dark blue and a purple.  This blog, I realize is just another form of those.  A digital document.  I wouldn’t want to imagine what this would equate to in terms of pages in those notebooks, my small print scrawled across every line of every page.

When my sister died I was so careful with my words.  People would send letters of encouragement, and I would spend hours writing back.  The notes in return would be brief, but they would say only what I meant to say, precisely and exactly and no more.  I would not admit to the grand scale of my emotional weakness or development.  I would not infer anything beyond a very stable picture of sadness.  I was focused on never saying that I had lost my sister, that there was a loss in the family.  We had lost nothing, nothing we could find again, anyway.  And I would become irrationally angry at people who would tell me they were sorry for my loss–angry internally, of course.  My sister was not a set of car keys that had been misplaced.  Her body had no more life, taken by the jagged metal of a truck. I’m sorry for what was taken would have been a better conversation starter.

I have been less careful with my words since starting this writing experience, so I wanted to again apologize for my own written diarrhea, and offshoot of the verbal wars in my head.  These thoughts of death and life, happiness and sadness, grief and glory all are topics that are so difficult to have with people in the real world.  Conversations filled with awkward silences and people struggle to find any words to respond.  These are conversations people are not used to having.  These conversations about how to become better when you are are not good are not easy for people to have.  I have had easier conversations about the color of cheese and “So You Think You Can Dance” and other inane and banal topics, but this blog and these words are the real content of my heart.

So I will be careful with my words once again as I begin to emerge from my cocoon of grief and sadness and mourning and realize that my unfiltered thoughts can, at times, be quite dramatic, raw, and thoughtless.  I will comfort myself with the song “Everything’s Not Lost” by Coldplay.  A companion to yellow.  My favorite song on that album in conjunction with my sister’s.  Because everything’s not lost.  Not my sister.  Not most things.